The film, directed and produced by David Heilbroner and Kate Davis,
who won an Emmy Award for her 2004 HBO documentary "Jockey," positions
itself as the antidote to television shows like "Extreme Makeover" and
"The Swan." Those reality programs, both now defunct, promoted plastic
surgeons as fairy godmothers, transforming patients (after hours on
the operating table and months of recovery time) from frumpy Cinderellas
to plasticized clones of Pamela Anderson. "Plastic Disasters" takes
the opposite point of view, that plastic surgery is not a welcome boost
to self-esteem. The show posits cosmetic surgery as an agent of total
ruination, leaving its victims scarred, both physically and emotionally.
The documentary is gruesomely compelling, complete with shots of gore
and gangrene. It focuses on three patients who have had bad experiences:
Mona, who had a botched liposuction; Tony, who undergoes a series of
operations to correct a faulty nose job; and Lucille, who, after a nose
job and two face lifts, is obsessed with her appearance.